18 Shake vs Shakeology – Which One Should You Choose?

(Last Updated On: April 25, 2018)

Both 18 Shake and Shakeology are some of the best and most popular protein supplements in the United States. These brands have acquired millions of loyal consumers and both of them can be used as healthy meal replacements. But which of these two shakes will work better when it comes to losing weight and maintaining a healthy organism? You’re about to discover that as well as many other interesting aspects of these products.

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Brief Comparison

18 ShakeShakeology
IngredientsNatural ingredientsProprietary blends
Available flavors27
Number of natural ingredients18>70
Calories per serving90150-200
Manufacturing company18 NutritionBeachbody
Price per bag$47.99$129.95
Rating on Amazon3.4 out of 5 stars2.7 out of 5 stars

18 Shake vs Shakeology – What They Are

18 Shake

This is a popular weight-loss plan that focuses on meal replacements. In other words, dieters will have to replace a couple of their daily meals with 18 Shake’s nutritional beverages. Furthermore, the company also provides a useful eBook that guides you while you’re consuming these shakes.

18 Shake supplements are created by 18 Nutrition Company which is located in California. According to its manufacturer, 18 Shakes meal replacements contain 18 natural ingredients like proteins, vitamins, fiber, and minerals. They are marketed in two available flavors: chocolate and vanilla.

Shakeology

This is another popular and powerful superfood formula that was specially designed to provide your body with the perfect mix of essential nutrients to boost your energy levels, lower cravings, support a healthy immune system, and help you lose weight in a safe manner. The brand’s main products are its protein shakes which can replace one or even two of your daily meals.

Well, to be honest, it is quite hard to accurately classify Shakeology because it is more than a simple protein shake but it is not truly a complete meal replacement either. These beverages are very dynamic and classifying them in a simplistic way will only limit their complex characteristics. Instead of substituting an entire meal, these shakes can only be part of a meal so you should combine them with whole foods like fruits, veggies, or nuts.

Shakeology’s formula contains more than 70 different natural ingredients that include super greens, proteins, phytonutrients, super fruits, probiotics, and others. It comes in a wide range of available varieties and it is one of the best products of its kind on the market. Shakeology’s manufacturer and the seller is Beachbody.

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Ingredient Profile

18 Shake

You can find the entire list of ingredients on both the product’s label and on the company’s official website which is something I really appreciate about a supplement. Still, I felt the need to investigate the ingredient profile a little further and here is what I found. 18 Shake is a low-calorie product that is rich in vitamins and fibers. These powders contain the following main compounds:

  • Protein blend – whey isolate and whey concentrate. Because protein’s metabolic process lasts longer than other elements, your organism will be forced to burn more calories. Not only will this aspect help you lose weight but it will also keep you fuller for a longer time.
  • Stevia – this natural sweetener doesn’t affect your blood sugar level as much as other types of sugar. Furthermore, it doesn’t lead to weight gain or tooth decay.
  • Fibersol-2 – this compound is an effective appetite suppressant and supports a low-calorie intake. Some say it might even balance blood sugar levels while also curbing cravings.
  • Vitamin and mineral blend – vitamins B and C, potassium, calcium, phosphorus, chromium, iodine, magnesium, copper. This formula boosts metabolism, supports a healthy thyroid gland, increases your energy and focus, burns carbs, regulates blood pressure, and improves your overall immune system.
  • Natural cocoa – has antioxidant properties and it is a very nutritious ingredient.

Shakeology

Shakeology’s manufacturer opted for an original formula based solely on proprietary blends:

  • Protein blend – includes pea, chia, whey, quinoa, flax, etc. Proteins support the process of bones, muscles, and cartilage creation. Also, they improve the health of your blood and skin.
  • Phytonutrient blend – chlorella, spinach, moringa, spirulina, kale. All these elements lower the risks of severe and chronic illnesses such as cancer and cardiovascular conditions. They fight free radicals and their oxidative stress effect.
  • Antioxidant blend – acerola cherry, rose hips, green tea, Camu-Camu, goji berry, etc. Antioxidants prevent plenty of diseases and they improve the way your skin looks. Furthermore, they support your immune system and keep your heart, eyesight, and nervous system healthy.
  • Adaptogen blend – Maca, Reishi, Astragalus, Ashwagandha, Maitake, Cordyceps, and Schisandra. Adaptogens lower stress, balance your mood, boost immunity, regulate hormonal imbalances, improves cognitive functions, and have powerful anti-fatigue properties.
  • Digestive enzyme blend – pro and prebiotics such as cellulase, yacon root, amylase, lactase, etc. Digestive enzymes alleviate acid reflux symptoms and they prevent nutritional deficiencies.

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Nutritional Values

18 Shake

18 Shake Nutritional Facts – per one serving (one scoop of approx. 27 g)
Calories90
Proteins15 g
Carbohydrates8 g
Total fat1 g
Dietary fiber5 g
Sugars1 g
Sodium19 mg

Shakeology

Shakeology Nutritional Facts – per one serving (one packet of 47.5 g)
Calories150-200
Proteins20 g
Carbohydrates16 g
Total fat6 g
Dietary fiber3 g
Sugars6 g 220 mg
Sodium

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Taste and Mixability

18 Shake

There are two available 18 Shake flavors: vanilla and chocolate. Some consumers said they simply love the way these shakes taste while most people stated the flavor is very similar to the one of any other similar supplement. If you find it difficult to ingest these beverages as they are, you can always combine them with fresh or frozen fruits, vegetables, and even nuts. My personal favorite variety is chocolate and I would always choose it over the vanilla variety.

18 Shake powder is easy to prepare. Just mix one scoop of this product with any beverage of your choice. You can prepare the beverage in a blender if you want to obtain a smooth texture. Otherwise, you can also place the mix in a shaker cup for a better consistency and to avoid clumps.

Shakeology

One aspect I truly like about these shakes is their wide range of available flavors:

  • Vanilla;
  • Chocolate;
  • Strawberry;
  • Greenberry;
  • Café latte;
  • Tropical strawberry vegan;
  • Chocolate vegan.

When it comes to Shakeology’s taste, people’s opinions vary quite a lot. Some say they have a pleasant taste while others don’t really like it. Still, certain flavors are more delicious than others. For example, vanilla, chocolate, and strawberry varieties are the company’s bestsellers. The least favorite flavor is Greenberry which has a tangy taste.

I’ve noticed that the manufacturer is constantly working on improving the taste and consistency of these shakes. All in all, Shakeology tastes pretty good although it doesn’t provide an over-the-top flavor. In terms of mixability, you can easily combine this powder with any liquid of your choice such as soy milk, water, organic juice, etc.

UPDATE! Shakeology has recently launched two more flavors that target vegan and vegetarian audiences: café latte vegan and vanilla vegan.

Pros and Cons

18 Shake

Pros

  • Contains only natural ingredients and it is free of artificial flavorings;
  • Boosts one’s energy levels;
  • It can be used as a meal replacement;
  • Speeds up the weight-loss process and lowers the sensation of hunger;
  • It tastes good and it is low in sugar, containing stevia which is a natural sweetener;
  • Supports a healthy metabolic rate and balanced immune system;
  • It is high in vitamins, minerals, proteins, and fiber;
  • This product is very easy to prepare and highly convenient.

Cons

  • There’s a risk of some mild yet annoying side effects like bloating and nausea;
  • You can only purchase these shakes online;
  • Sometimes, the seller is out of stock which can be quite frustrating.

Shakeology

Pros

  • It is formulated with high-quality ingredients;
  • Promotes lean muscle mass growth;
  • Boosts immunity and helps your overall health;
  • The manufacturer also sells both vegan and vegetarian alternatives;
  • It is easy to prepare and it mixes well with plenty of liquids;
  • It is a non-GMO supplement;
  • Although it is not really a meal replacement, it can easily be consumed as a healthy and nutritious snack.

Cons

  • It is pretty expensive;
  • Some users say they did not like the taste of these shakes;
  • A few consumers claim that certain ingredients are totally unnecessary. This is the case of pea protein.

Possible Side Effects

18 Shake

Usually, these protein shakes don’t have any side effects, especially due to the fact that they contain natural and safe ingredients. However, more sensitive people might experience several unpleasant symptoms such as:

  • Bloating;
  • Cramps and an upset stomach;
  • Nausea;
  • Fatigue;
  • Headaches.

Shakeology

Shakeology shakes are pretty safe to consume but if you deal with a serious health condition or if you’re allergic to any of this product’s ingredients, you should either avoid drinking it or seek your doctor’s advice first.

The most common potential side effects are:

  • Insomnia or fatigue;
  • Stomach cramps;
  • Diarrhea or constipation;
  • Headaches;
  • Vomiting;
  • Allergic reactions.

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Purchasing Options and Pricing

18 Shake

You can either purchase 18 Shake from the company’s official Internet page or from third-party online sellers like Amazon.

If you opt for the first alternative, you will benefit from a limited time offer that translates into a 40% discount. They are currently selling their supplement for the price of $47.99 per bag. All you have to do to order 18 Shake is to complete the brief form you will find on their page. Besides one bag of powder, you will also get a free eBook that will teach you how to eat and cook properly in order to lose weight. Moreover, the package also contains a shaker cup.

All orders are eligible for the company’s money-back guarantee and the shipping is totally free of charge.

On Amazon, you can buy a minimum of two packages which will come with a free eBook and an extra free 18 Shake bag. The total price is almost $179 and the shipping cost is $4.49 so purchasing this product on Amazon is more expensive than buying it on the company’s online page.

Shakeology

Shakeology can be found on Beachbody’s official website. There, one bag of protein powder costs $129.95 which is quite expensive but some of you might consider the price totally worth it due to the fact that we’re talking about a premium and high-quality supplement. You can either buy a box with 24 individual packets or a large resealable bag that contains 30 servings.

In terms of order type, clients can opt for a monthly authorship program that provides super discount shipping. The second alternative is a one-time order. Monthly subscribers will also benefit from a $2 deduction per unit. Another perk is the 30-day money-back guarantee applied by the company.

On Amazon, all I could find was a mixed package of Shakeology and 3 Day Refresh supplements, both delivered by Beachbody. The package includes three individual bags of Shakeology, six Vanilla Fresh packets, three Fiber Sweep packets, and a program guide. The total cost is $82.90.

18 Shake vs Shakeology – Final Verdict

It can be hard to choose between these two supplements because they both provide plenty of nutrients as well as health benefits. It all depends on what your budget, personal preference, and needs are. For example, if you’re trying to lose weight by consuming a less expensive meal replacement, I recommend you to go with 18 Shake. This product might lack some of the minerals and vitamins that Shakeology offers but it is just as nutritious as its competitor.

If you ask me, I would say that my favorite option is 18 Shake. It is true that Shakeology contains superfoods and probiotics but you can get those nutrients from whole foods.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.