The Top 3 Best Organic Protein Supplements – Pure Ingredients

Last Updated on

Protein powder is a vital part of your muscle-building diet and lifestyle! Not only does it provide the amino acids needed to pack on the muscle, but it also helps to provide the calories, carbs, fats, and nutrients to help your body repair itself after the “damage” it sustained during your workout (don’t worry, this is good damage that promotes muscle growth).

There are literally HUNDREDS of protein powders on the market today. You can find whey and casein protein made from milk, egg proteins, soy protein, pea protein, hemp protein, rice protein, and the list goes on and on!But with all these options, it’s hard to know which protein powder is the best. You want to choose powders that not only pack a nutrient punch, but which are as natural and effective as possible.

Finding non-GMO (non soy protein), fully organic protein powder is always a plus, as that’s the best way to be certain you’re getting a truly HEALTHY product.

Please note, this list is primarily for Whey based organic supplements. For Vegans, I’d recommend checking out my Garden of Life Organic review here.

We’ve done the research and found the three best organic protein supplements for you. They may be a bit pricier than the non-organic stuff (the more popular products), but they’re worth it if you’re looking for organic ingredients and top quality!

#1 Pick: Source Organic Whey Protein


If your goal is to bulk up, whey protein powder is usually your best bet. It’s fast-acting, easily digested, and one of the most stomach-friendly protein powders around. It’s rare to find an organic whey protein powder, but thankfully, Source Organic has a product for you!

About the Protein Powder:

  • Certified organic
  • Verified GMO-free
  • Contains a proper blend of amino acids
  • Free of soy, gluten, and hormones
  • Produced with no artificial flavors, colors, preservatives, or sweeteners
  • Non-denatured, cold-processed

This whey protein powder is made from the milk produced by grass-fed Jersey cows from Northern California. The fact that the cows are grass-fed means the protein powder has a higher amino acid profile. It is certified GMO-free and 100% organic, and it has a natural flavor that sits well when you mix it with your protein shakes and smoothies.

Here’s what customers have to say about it on Amazon.


“This is a basic organic whey protein with nothing added to it. The flavor is simple, and even the packaging is biodegradable!””Source Organic’s Whey Protein mixes very well, and it doesn’t form clumps (like regular protein powder tends to).”

“The price is competitive (for an organic protein powder), but it’s the taste that has made me a repeat buyer. Source tastes fresher and purer than other brands. Mixing it with water gives it a refreshing, clean, and almost sweet flavor, with no aftertaste.”

“This protein…is raw and unpasteurized, and has a high glutathione content.”


“The resealable pouch is a good concept, but the seal doesn’t work.””It has a bit of a cooked/freeze-dried taste, but better than some others.”

The product is a bit pricey–roughly $32.50 per pound (For the latest prices and discounts, check here). Compare that to your average whey protein powder ($35 to $60 for 5 pounds), and you can see why it’s not available in every store in the country. Still, if you’re looking for a whey protein powder and MUST have organic, this is definitely the product for you. You can check out the latest deals here.

Best Pick: Naked Oats Whey + Organic Oat Protein Powder


If you’re looking for a cheaper whey protein powder than the Source Organics product at the top of the list, you’ll love this one! Produced by NAKED Nutrition, it’s a combination of whey protein and organic oat flour and fiber to give you a nutrient punch to start out your day!

About the Protein Powder:

  • Made from organic whole oat flour and oat fiber, grown in Canada and the US
  • Contains whey protein from grass-fed cows
  • Balances protein, complex carbs, and protein to be a complete workout supplement
  • No artificial sweeteners or additives
  • 26 grams of protein per serving/contains all nine amino acids for muscle-building
  • Mechanically-processed oats and Cold-processed whey

While it’s not pure protein, it is an excellent supplement to kick off your day right. It contains fiber and carbs from the oat flour, helping you to get your digestion on track. With the shot of protein in every scoop, you’ll kick your metabolism into overdrive with this as a breakfast shake.

Here’s what customers have to say on Amazon:


“It’s pretty delicious! It is bland-tasting, making it perfect for blending…kind of like powdered milk, but with an aftertaste of oatmeal.”

“It’s gentle on my stomach, and tastes just like whey and oats.”

“The taste is neutral and inoffensive, and can be taken with either water or milk.”

“Mixes well with other proteins.”

“Contains less sugar and more protein than Optimum Nutrition’s Whey.”


“It foams up quite a bit, and comes out lumpy. Contains powdery residue that sinks to the bottom, no matter how much you mix it.”

“Drinking it with water is just plain foul. It HAS to be mixed with milk, into a smoothie, or used for baking.”

While it may not be quite as popular as the Source Organic protein powder that was our #1 pick, there’s a lot to love about it. The balance of carbs, fiber, and protein makes it a great choice for those who want to start their day out right. See here to save about 25% of the list price.

Runner Up: Orgain Organic Plant-Based Protein Powder

If you’re a vegetarian or vegan looking for an alternative to milk or egg-based protein powders, this plant-based organic protein powder is the ideal option! Not only does it pack a protein punch, but it comes in delicious flavors like chocolate and vanilla. You can check out my full review of Orgain that I did a few months ago here.

About the Protein Powder:

  • Made from organic hemp, pea, chia, and brown rice protein
  • Contains 21 grams of organic plant-based protein per serving
  • No added sugar
  • Contains 3 grams of net carbs (total carbs minus fiber = net carbs)
  • Soy, dairy, and gluten-free
  • Non-GMO, USDA Certified Organic

Plant-based proteins aren’t as effective for muscle-building as whey, casein, and egg protein powders, but they are a good option for vegans/vegetarians looking to supplement their protein intake. This vanilla and chocolate-flavored protein powder has been specifically formulated to avoid that nasty aftertaste that is so common with plant-based protein powders.

Here’s what customers are saying about it on Amazon:


“The taste is delicious and creamy, and it’s so clean. I actually look forward to drinking this every day.”

“We don’t notice the grainy texture common with plant-based proteins, and it has a nice flavor. We’re pleased all around!”

“I love that it contains just 150 calories per serving–less than other plant-based protein powders.”

“One of the best-tasting protein powders I have tried.”


“If you are trying to stay lean (maintain weight rather than bulking up), this is not the product for you.”

“It has a nasty artificial sweetener aftertaste. This is due to the fact that it contains both erythritol and Stevia.”

“It’s too sweet for my preference, and has a weird aftertaste.”

For just $33 for a 2-pound tub (For the latest prices and discounts, check here), it’s pretty great value, and a decent product for vegans and vegetarians! It may not be the best-tasting protein powder around, but it will give you all the protein you need to stay healthy and bulk up in your vegetarian diet and lifestyle.

Comparing the Top Organic Protein Powders

The following table is an expanded view of my other top recommendations (all organic, high-quality protein, and vegan protein powder), so you can compare the key facts at a glance:

Click Here for Latest Price21gPea w/amaranth, artichoke, and quinoa1204g2g390mg
Click Here for Latest Price26gPea, SaviSeed, brown rice, and alfalfa1314.5g0.2g229mg
Click Here for Latest Price19gPea, hemp, and cranberry1002g2g320mg
Click Here for Latest Price17gBrown rice w/amaranth, quinoa, millet, buckwheat, garbanzo bean, lentil, flax seed, sunflower, pumpkin seed, chia seed, and seasame seed904g0g0g
Click Here for Latest Price22gPea, rice, hemp, and chia seed1309g1g220mg

Still Can’t Decide? Other Organic Proteins to Check Out

I’ve been reviewing protein supplements for over 5 years now, so I’ve built up quite the library of research. The Following are some other organic protein supplements that you may want to consider/look  into:

Or, you can also view some of my related round-up guides if you fit the demographic:

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.